REGULATION AND ENFORCEMENT OF CORPORATE INSIDER DEALINGS IN SOUTH AFRICA: DOES THE EXTANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK OFFER SUFFICIENT PROTECTION TO INVESTORS?
Abstract
The securities market represents a very important component of the financial sector in every free-market economy. Ensuring market discipline, integrity and transparency with the over-all protection of the investing public is critical to the wellness of a capital market and a financial system. The need for an effective legal framework that would guarantee a fair and economically safe securities market built on sound policy and practical consideration has therefore become compelling. One corporate ill besetting the securities markets in all jurisdictions is insider trading. Apart from being unethical, insider trading is disruptive of market dynamics. In South Africa, over the years, successive Acts had been enacted, amended and repealed to ensure discipline and protect the integrity of the nation’s securities market. In 2012, the current legislation, Financial Markets Act (FMA), was enacted to improve among others, the enforcement of insider trading regulation in South Africa. The regulation and enforcement of insider trading in terms of the FMA are however insufficient. This article therefore seeks to interrogate whether the FMA offers adequate protection to the investing public in South Africa against the menace of insider trading. The authors conclude that the regulation and enforcement of insider trading in terms of the FMA is insufficient and posit that with creative and appropriate reforms of the FMA, the investing public will be adequately protected against insider trading and investors’ confidence and the financial markets’ integrity and efficiency will be better enhanced.
About the Authors
Olufemi OluyejuSouth Africa
LLD (University of Pretoria). Senior Lecturer, Department of Public Law, School of Law, University of Venda, Thohoyandou, Limpopo, South Africa, 0950.
Maria Ifeoluwa Oluyeju
Tulane University
United States
SJD (equivalent to a Ph.D.) (Tulane University), LL.M. (Cornell University); LL.M. (University of Pretoria); LL.B. (University of Pretoria). Email address: moluyeju@tulane.edu.
References
1. Bibliography
2. PRIMARY SOURCES
3. Case law
4. Francis George Hill Family Trust v South African Reserve Bank and Others 1992 (3) SA 91 (AD).
5. Gardener and Another v S 2011 (4) SA 79 (SCA).
6. Ingledew v Financial Services Board 2003 (4) SA 584 (CC).
7. Investec Bank Ltd v Lambrechts NO and others [2014] ZAWCHC 175 (WC).
8. Mpakathi v Kgotso Development CC and Others [2006] 3 All SA 518 (SCA).
9. Multiple Access Ltd v McCutcheonand others (1982) 138 DLR (3d) 18 (SCC).
10. Pather and Another v Financial Services Board and Others 2014 (9) BCLR 1082 (GNP).
11. Platinum Asset Management (Pty) Ltd v Financial Services Board and Others; Anglo Rand Capital House (Pty) Ltd and Others v Financial Services Board and Others 2006 (4) SA 73 (W).
12. S v Lawrence, S v Negal; S v Solberg 1997 (4) SA 1176 (CC).
13. S v Selebi [2010] ZAGPJHC 53 (GNJ).
14. Stevens and Others v Investec Bank Ltd and Others 2009 (6) SA 277 (GSJ).
15. Zietsman and another v Directorate of Market Abuse and another (A679/14) (24 August 2015).
16. Legislation
17.
18. Canada Business Corporations Act of 1985.
19. Canada Corporations Act of 1970.
20. Financial Markets Act 19 of 2012.
21. Insider Trading Act 135 of 1998.
22. Interpretation Act 33 of 1957.
23. Ontario Business Corporations Act of 1982.
24. Ontario Securities Act of 1966.
25. Ontario Securities’ Act of 1990.
26. Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
27. Securities Services Act 36 of 2004.
28. SECONDARY SOURCES
29. Books
30. Cassim F et al (2012) The Law of Business Structures Juta: Claremont.
31. Cassim F et al (2012) Contemporary Company Law Juta: Claremont.
32. David D (2009) Companies and other business structures in South Africa Oxford University Press: Cape Town.
33. Delport P (2014) New Entrepreneurial Law Durban: LexisNexis.
34. Jooste R (2011) The Comparative Guide to the Old and New Companies’ Acts Juta: Claremont.
35. Martin J et al (1988) The theory of finance: evidence and application Chicago : Dryden Press.
36. Rinehart & Winston Introduction to research in education (1985).
37. .
38. Seidman A and Seidman R (1994) State and Law in the development process: problem solving and institutional change in the third world New York: St. Martin’s Press.
39. Spratt S, (2009) Development Finance: debates, dogmas and new directions London: Routledge.
40. Articles
41. Beny L & Anand A ‘Private Regulation of Insider Trading in the Shadow of Lax Public Enforcement: Evidence from Canadian Firms’ (2013) 3 Harvard Law Review 215.
42. Botha D ‘Control of Insider Trading in South Africa: A Comparative Analysis’ (1991) 3 SA Merc LJ 64.
43. Cassim R ‘Some Aspects of Insider Trading – Has the Securities Services Act 36 of 2004 Gone too Far?’ (2007) 19 SA Merc LJ 44.
44. Chitimira H & Lawack V ‘An Analysis of the General Enforcement approaches to combat market abuse’ (2013) 33 Obiter 64.
45. Chitimira H ‘A Historical Overview of the Regulation of Market Abuse in South Africa’ (2014) 17 Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal 937.
46. Chitimira H ‘A historical overview of the regulation of market abuse under the Securities Services Act 36 of 2004’ (2014) 47 De Jure 310.
47. Chitimira H ‘Overview of Problems Associated with Ineffective Enforcement of Market Abuse Provisions in South Africa’ (2014) 5 Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences 47.
48. Chitimira H ‘Overview of the Available Remedies for Market Abuse Victims under the Financial Markets Act 19 of 2012’ (2014) 8 Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences 124.
49. Chitimira H ‘Overview of the Market Abuse Regulation under the Financial Markets Act 19 of 2012’ (2014) 35 Obiter 254.
50. Chitimira H ‘Selected challenges in the South African anti-market abuse enforcement framework in relation to some aspects of the financial markets’ (2014) 35 Obiter 584.
51. Chitimira H ‘The Consummation of Anti-Market Abuse Preventative Measures in Australia: Lessons for South Africa’ (2015) 42(3) Journal of Social Sciences 211.
52. Chitimira H ‘The Inherent Challenges in the South African Anti-Market Abuse Enforcement Framework in Relation to Selected Market Abuse Practices that Occurred During the’ (2014) 5 Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences 60.
53. Chitimira H ‘The Regulation of Insider Trading in Canada: A Historical Comparative Perspective’ (2014) 5 Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences 144.
54. Condon M ‘A Discipline In Search Of Itself? Contemporary Challenges For Securities Law In Canada’ (2014) 65 University of Brunswick Law Journal 341.
55. Jooste R ‘A critique of the insider trading provisions of the 2004 Securities Services Act’ (2006) 123 South African Law Journal 437.
56. Kawadza H ‘A Comment on the Liability Regime introduced by section 65 of the Financial Services Law General Amendment Act 45 of 2013’ (2014) 131 SA Law Journal 131.
57. Luiz S & van der Linde K ‘The Financial Markets Act 19 of 2012: Some Comments on the Regulation of Market Abuse’ (2013) 35 SA Merc LJ 458.
58. Luiz S ‘Insider Trading: A Transplant to Cure a Chronic Illness?’ (1990) 2 SA Merc LJ 59.
59. Luiz S ‘Market abuse and the enforcement committee’ (2011) 23 SA Merc LJ 151.
60. Luiz S ‘The Companies Act 71 of 2008 and the Disclosure of and Rights of Access to Information about Securities’ (2014) 26 SA Merc LJ 167.
61. Ojah K et al ‘Market Reaction and Equity Market Efficiency: A Survey of the Insider Trading Law in South Africa’ (2008) 10 The Africa Finance Journal 1.
62. Osode P ‘Insider Trading Regulation In South Africa: A Public Choice Perspective’ (1999) 11 RADIC 688.
63. Osode P ‘Regulatory theory, private interests and the rationality of insider trading regulation in the United States and Canada’ (1998) 3 Journal of South African Law 427.
64. Ryder S ‘How to Prevent Future Flash Crashes and Restore the Ordinary Investors' Confidence in the Financial Market: the Implementation of Circuit Breakers and Speed Limits to Help Enforce the Market Access Rule’ (2014) 12 Journal of Telecomm and High Tech Law 265.
65. Shongwe M & Ratshitanga ‘Insider Trading’ (2012) 12 Without Prejudice 64.
66. Swart L & Lawack-Davids V ‘Understanding the South African financial markets: an overview of the regulators’ (2010) 31 Obiter 619.
67. Thornicroft K ‘On the Road to National Securities Regulation: Blockade or Detour?’ (2013) 71 Advocate Vancouver 525.
68. Wihau A et al ‘Corporate Governance Practices in Canada and the United States’ (2014) 3 Drake Management Review 66.
69. Theses and dissertations
70. Kwasi O (2014) What is really wrong with Insider Trading? unpublished LLM thesis, University of Cape Town.
71. Chitimira H (2008) The Regulation of Insider Trading in South Africa: A Roadmap for an Effective, Competitive and Adequate Regulatory Statutory Framework unpublished LLM thesis, University of Fort Hare.
72. Internet sources
73. https://www.fsb.co.za/Departments/marketAbuse/Documents/DMA%20Past%20Investigations.pdf (accessed 26/03/2015).
74. https://www.jse.co.za/content/JSERulesPoliciesandRegulationItems/Insider%20Trading%20Booklet.pdf (accessed 04/04/2015).
75. https://www.osc.gov.on.ca/en/Companies_insider-reporting_index.htm (accessed 28/07/2015).
76. http://0-www.osc.gov.on.ca.innopac.up.ac.za/en/search.htm?gquery=insider+trading (accessed 28/07/2015).
77. http://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90s05 (accessed 28/07/2015).
78. https://0-www.osc.gov.on.ca.innopac.up.ac.za/en/Marketplaces_bgrd_20140515_23-101_order-protection-rule.htm (accessed 28/07/2015).
79. http://0-www.osc.gov.on.ca.innopac.up.ac.za/en/47347.htm (accessed 28/07/2015).
80. https://0-www.osc.gov.on.ca.innopac.up.ac.za/en/InvestmentFunds_ifunds_20140327_practitioner.htm (accessed 28/07/2015).
81. http://www.hedgefund-index.com/d_shortselling.asp (accessed 16/09/2015).
82. http://www.millerthomson.com/en/publications/newsletters/securities-practice-notes/2010-archives/spring-2010/canadas-first-criminal-conviction-for-illegal (accessed 17/09/2015).
83. https://www.gov.uk/whistleblowing/what-is-a-whistleblower (accessed 21/09/2015).
84. Reports
85. The King Task Group into Insider Trading Legislation Minority Report on Insider Trading 1997.
86. The King Task Group into the Insider Trading Legislation Final Report 21 October 1997.
87. The King Task Group into the Insider Trading Legislation First Report 15 May 1997.
88. Van Wyk de Vries Commission of Inquiry into the Companies Act of 1973.
89. Ontario Securities Commission Bulletin, July 30 2015, Volume 38 Issue 30.
90. Ontario Securities Commission Annual Report (Financial Statements) 2015.
91. Ontario Securities Commission Annual Report (Management’s Discussion and Analysis) 2015.
92. Ontario Securities Commission Annual Report 2014.
93. Government Gazettes
94. South Africa (2001) Stock Exchanges Control Amendment Act, 2000. (Proclamation No. R. 22892, 2000) December 5 (Regulation Gazette No. 1281).
Review
For citations:
Oluyeju O., Oluyeju M.I. REGULATION AND ENFORCEMENT OF CORPORATE INSIDER DEALINGS IN SOUTH AFRICA: DOES THE EXTANT LEGAL FRAMEWORK OFFER SUFFICIENT PROTECTION TO INVESTORS? BRICS Law Journal. 2022;9(1).
Email this article 