Tax Challenges Arising from the Digitalisation of the Economy: the development of the OECD project and possible implementation in Russia
Abstract
The article discusses the initiatives of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (hereinafter – the OECD) in the area of taxation of international groups of companies in the era of the digital economy. Methodological approaches to taxation of the digital economy are considered, the features of digitalization of the economy that play an important role for tax policy are highlighted. The digitalization of economy has caused a number of complex problems in the area of taxation, mainly related to the issue of distribution of taxing rights between states in the context of taxing income received as a result of cross-border activities.
The study is based on a comparative legal method that allows comparing similar legal problems existing in legislation and international treaties, as well as identifying optimal ways to resolve them. The following main problem of taxation of digital economy is highlighted: tax systems laid down in the 1920s traditionally took into account the principles of the source of income and residency. In the new world of globalization and the digital economy, these principles become significant obstacles to international trade. On this ground the issues of the new nexus as well as the new model of allocation of taxing rights should be established.
The analysis of the OECD two-pillar approach is brought into light. Pillar 1 deals with the reallocation of profit of multinational enterprises to market jurisdictions. Pillar 2 deals with a Global Minimum Tax.
The possible ways of implementation of the new OECD concept in Russia are also discussed in the article.
About the Author
KARINA PONOMAREVARussian Federation
Leading Researcher at the Tax Policy Center, Financial Research Institute under the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation,
Professor, Department for State and Municipal Law, Dostoevsky Omsk State University
References
1. Берберов А.Б., Милоголов Н.С. Оценка масштабов проблемы размывания налоговой базы в России // Научно-исследовательский финансовый институт. Финансовый журнал. 2018. № 6. С. 47-58 [Berberov A.B., Milogolov N.S., Assessment of the Scope of Tax Base Erosion in Russia, 6 Financial Journal [Finansovyy zhurnal] 47 (2018)].
2. Котляров М.А., Рыкова И.Н. Противодействие переносу налоговой базы в низконалоговые юрисдикции: опыт ОЭСР и приоритеты для России // Финансовый журнал. 2014. № 4 (22). С. 47-54. [Maxim A. Kotlyarov & Inna N. Rycova, Prevention of tax base shifting to low-tax jurisdictions: OECD experience and priorities for Russia, 4 Financial journal [Finansovyy zhurnal] 47 (2014)].
3. Милоголов Н. С., Пономарева К.А. Международная кооперация налоговых администраций при налогообложении цифровых бизнес-моделей: миф или реальность? // Налоги. 2021. № 3. С. 29-33. [Milogolov N.S., Ponomareva K.A., International Cooperation of Tax Administrations in Taxing Digital Business Models: Myth or Reality?, 3 Nalogi 31 (2021)].
4. Becker J., Englisch J. Taxing Where Value Is Created: What’s ‘User Involvement’ Got to Do with It?, 47 Intertax 161 (2019).
5. Gustafson C.H., Peroni R.J., Pugh R.C. Taxation of International Transactions: materials, texts and problems (2006).
6. Devereux M.P. How Should Business Profit Be Taxed? Some Thoughts on Conceptual Developments During the Lifetime of the IFS. Fiscal Studies, 40: 591 (2019).
7. Milogolov, N.S., Berberov, A.B. Russia in global digital tax reform: together or apart? 14(11) J. Sib. Fed. Univ. Humanit. soc. sci., 1731 (2021).
8. Ponomareva K. Comparison of Proposals to Adjust the Permanent Establishment Concept to the Digital Economy 73 Bull. Intl. Taxn. 581 (2019).
9. Schön W. Ten Questions about Why and How to Tax the Digitalized Economy, 72 Bull. Intl. Taxn. 4/5, sec. 11. (2018).
10. Sinnig J. The Reflection of Data-Driven Value Creation in the 2018 OECD and EU Proposals, 27, EC Tax Review 325 (2018).
Review
For citations:
PONOMAREVA K. Tax Challenges Arising from the Digitalisation of the Economy: the development of the OECD project and possible implementation in Russia. BRICS Law Journal. 2022;9(4).