<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Publishing DTD v1.3 20210610//EN" "JATS-journalpublishing1-3.dtd">
<article article-type="research-article" dtd-version="1.3" xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xml:lang="en"><front><journal-meta><journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">bricslawjournal</journal-id><journal-title-group><journal-title xml:lang="en">BRICS Law Journal</journal-title><trans-title-group xml:lang="ru"><trans-title>Юридический журнал БРИКС</trans-title></trans-title-group></journal-title-group><issn pub-type="ppub">2409-9058</issn><issn pub-type="epub">2412-2343</issn><publisher><publisher-name>Publishing House V.Ема</publisher-name></publisher></journal-meta><article-meta><article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.21684/2412-2343-2015-2-1-26-37</article-id><article-id custom-type="elpub" pub-id-type="custom">bricslawjournal-26</article-id><article-categories><subj-group subj-group-type="heading"><subject>Research Article</subject></subj-group><subj-group subj-group-type="section-heading" xml:lang="en"><subject>COMMENTS</subject></subj-group></article-categories><title-group><article-title>WRONGFUL TRADING: COMPARATIVE APPROACH (ENGLAND AND WALES,  RUSSIA  AND THE USA)</article-title><trans-title-group xml:lang="ru"><trans-title></trans-title></trans-title-group></title-group><contrib-group><contrib contrib-type="author" corresp="yes"><name-alternatives><name name-style="western" xml:lang="en"><surname>Konstantinov</surname><given-names>D.</given-names></name></name-alternatives><bio xml:lang="en"><p>Dmitry Konstantinov (Lipetsk, Russia) – Associate at  the  Ilyashev and Partners Law Firm </p><p>(2/1 Zoi Kosmodemyanskoi str., Lipetsk, 398005, Russia)</p></bio><email xlink:type="simple">dmkonstantinov@hotmail.com</email><xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-1"/></contrib></contrib-group><aff-alternatives id="aff-1"><aff xml:lang="en">Ilyashev &amp; Partners Law Firm, Lipetsk<country>Russian Federation</country></aff></aff-alternatives><pub-date pub-type="collection"><year>2015</year></pub-date><pub-date pub-type="epub"><day>24</day><month>06</month><year>2016</year></pub-date><volume>2</volume><issue>1</issue><fpage>100</fpage><lpage>124</lpage><permissions><copyright-statement>Copyright &amp;#x00A9; Konstantinov D., 2016</copyright-statement><copyright-year>2016</copyright-year><copyright-holder xml:lang="ru">Konstantinov D.</copyright-holder><copyright-holder xml:lang="en">Konstantinov D.</copyright-holder><license license-type="creative-commons-attribution" xlink:href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" xlink:type="simple"><license-p>This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.</license-p></license></permissions><self-uri xlink:href="https://www.bricslawjournal.com/jour/article/view/26">https://www.bricslawjournal.com/jour/article/view/26</self-uri><abstract><p>This paper is designed to discover legal rules addressing insolvency trading in three jurisdictions: England and Wales, Russia and the USA. Originally it was a master’s dissertation written under supervision of Ms. Sarah Paterson, who was extremely helpful and patient. The key jurisdiction for the research is England and Wales, whose wrongful trading provision apparently was the very first insolvency regulation in the field. Here, we will give particular attention to the factual circumstances of insolvency trading and research how the concept of wrongful trading addresses them. The next question will be how the American concept of deepening insolvency and the Russian concept of subsidiary liability are comparable with wrongful trading. Later, we will focus on the functions that should be performed by the regulations. Also, the effectiveness of wrongful trading and similar overseas provisions will be examined. Finally, this paper attempts to find obstacles to the wide application of wrongful trading provision.</p></abstract><kwd-group xml:lang="en"><kwd>wrongful trading</kwd><kwd>deepening insolvency</kwd><kwd>subsidiary liability</kwd><kwd>liability of directors</kwd></kwd-group></article-meta></front><back><ref-list><title>References</title><ref id="cit1"><label>1</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Apel, Sara E. In Too Deep: Why the Federal Courts Should Not Recognize Deepening Insolvency As A Cause of Action, 24 Emory Bankr. Dev. J. 85, 86 (2008).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Apel, Sara E. In Too Deep: Why the Federal Courts Should Not Recognize Deepening Insolvency As A Cause of Action, 24 Emory Bankr. Dev. J. 85, 86 (2008).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit2"><label>2</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Bechner, Thomas. Wrongful Trading – A New European Model for Creditor Protection?, 5 European Business Organization Law Review (EBOR) 293 (2004).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Bechner, Thomas. Wrongful Trading – A New European Model for Creditor Protection?, 5 European Business Organization Law Review (EBOR) 293 (2004).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit3"><label>3</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Brandt, William A., Jr., &amp; Vance, Catherine E. Deepening Insolvency and the United Kingdom’s Wrongful Trading Statute: A Comparative Discussion, 19 Insolvency Intelligence 156, 158 (2006).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Brandt, William A., Jr., &amp; Vance, Catherine E. Deepening Insolvency and the United Kingdom’s Wrongful Trading Statute: A Comparative Discussion, 19 Insolvency Intelligence 156, 158 (2006).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit4"><label>4</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Cook, Carol. Wrongful Trading: Is It a Real Threat to Directors or a Paper Tiger?, 1999 Insolvency Lawyer 99.</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Cook, Carol. Wrongful Trading: Is It a Real Threat to Directors or a Paper Tiger?, 1999 Insolvency Lawyer 99.</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit5"><label>5</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Cork, Kenneth. Insolvency Law and Practice: Report of Review Committee 29, 63, 388, 390, 399 (Her Majesty’s Stationery Office 1982).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Cork, Kenneth. Insolvency Law and Practice: Report of Review Committee 29, 63, 388, 390, 399 (Her Majesty’s Stationery Office 1982).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit6"><label>6</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Cross, Frank B. Tort Law and the American Economy, 96 Minn. L. Rev. 28 (2011), available at &lt;http://www.minnesotalawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Cross_MLR.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Cross, Frank B. Tort Law and the American Economy, 96 Minn. L. Rev. 28 (2011), available at &lt;http://www.minnesotalawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/Cross_MLR.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit7"><label>7</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Doyle, Louis g. Anomalies in the Wrongful Trading Provisions, 13 Company Law 96 (1992).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Doyle, Louis g. Anomalies in the Wrongful Trading Provisions, 13 Company Law 96 (1992).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit8"><label>8</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Finch, Vanessa. Corporate Insolvency Law: Perspectives and Principles 678, 699 (2nd ed., Cambridge university Press 2009).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Finch, Vanessa. Corporate Insolvency Law: Perspectives and Principles 678, 699 (2nd ed., Cambridge university Press 2009).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit9"><label>9</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Goode, Royston M. Wrongful Trading and the Balance Sheet Test of Insolvency, 1989 J. Bus. L. 436.</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Goode, Royston M. Wrongful Trading and the Balance Sheet Test of Insolvency, 1989 J. Bus. L. 436.</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit10"><label>10</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Hansmann, Henry, &amp; Kraakman, Reinier. The End of History for Corporate Law (Yale Law School, Program for Studies in Law, Economics, and Public Policy, Law and Economics Working Paper No. 235; New York university, Center for Law and Business, Law and Economics Working Paper No. 013; Harvard Law School, John M. Olin Center for Law, Economics, and Business Discussion Paper No. 280; Yale School of Management, International Center for Finance Working Paper No. 00-09, January 2000), &lt;http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=204528&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Hansmann, Henry, &amp; Kraakman, Reinier. The End of History for Corporate Law (Yale Law School, Program for Studies in Law, Economics, and Public Policy, Law and Economics Working Paper No. 235; New York university, Center for Law and Business, Law and Economics Working Paper No. 013; Harvard Law School, John M. Olin Center for Law, Economics, and Business Discussion Paper No. 280; Yale School of Management, International Center for Finance Working Paper No. 00-09, January 2000), &lt;http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=204528&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit11"><label>11</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Hicks, Andrew. Advising on Wrongful Trading: Part 1, 14 Company Lawyer 16 (1993).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Hicks, Andrew. Advising on Wrongful Trading: Part 1, 14 Company Lawyer 16 (1993).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit12"><label>12</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Ho, Look Chan. On Deepening Insolvency and Wrongful Trading, 20 Journal of International Banking Law &amp; Regulation 426 (2005), available at &lt;http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=741024&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Ho, Look Chan. On Deepening Insolvency and Wrongful Trading, 20 Journal of International Banking Law &amp; Regulation 426 (2005), available at &lt;http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=741024&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit13"><label>13</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Keay, Andrew. Company Directors’ Responsibilities to Creditors (Routledge-Cavendish 2007).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Keay, Andrew. Company Directors’ Responsibilities to Creditors (Routledge-Cavendish 2007).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit14"><label>14</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Keay, Andrew. Wrongful Trading and the Liability of Company Directors: A Theoretical Perspective, 25 Legal Stud. 431, 439 (2005). doi:10.1111/j.1748-121X.2005.tb00678.xKeay, Andrew. Wrongful Trading: Problems and Proposals, 65 N. Ir. Legal Q. 63, 70–72, 75 (2014), available at &lt;http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/78501/&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Keay, Andrew. Wrongful Trading and the Liability of Company Directors: A Theoretical Perspective, 25 Legal Stud. 431, 439 (2005). doi:10.1111/j.1748-121X.2005.tb00678.xKeay, Andrew. Wrongful Trading: Problems and Proposals, 65 N. Ir. Legal Q. 63, 70–72, 75 (2014), available at &lt;http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/78501/&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit15"><label>15</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Kershaw, David. Company Law in Context: Text and Materials 788 (2nd ed., Oxford university Press 2012).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Kershaw, David. Company Law in Context: Text and Materials 788 (2nd ed., Oxford university Press 2012).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit16"><label>16</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Markel, Dan. How Should Punitive Damages Work?, 157 u. Pa. L. Rev. 1383, 1392 (2012), available at &lt;https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/files/90-markel157upalrev13832009pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Markel, Dan. How Should Punitive Damages Work?, 157 u. Pa. L. Rev. 1383, 1392 (2012), available at &lt;https://www.law.upenn.edu/live/files/90-markel157upalrev13832009pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit17"><label>17</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Milman, David. Disqualification of Directors: An Evaluation of Current Law, Policy and Practice in the UK, 2013(331) Company Law Newsletter 1.</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Milman, David. Disqualification of Directors: An Evaluation of Current Law, Policy and Practice in the UK, 2013(331) Company Law Newsletter 1.</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit18"><label>18</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Munnery, Jonathan. What Is Insolvent Trading and Wrongful Trading in Business?, &lt;http://www.realbusinessrescue.co.uk/business-insolvency/wrongful-trading&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Munnery, Jonathan. What Is Insolvent Trading and Wrongful Trading in Business?, &lt;http://www.realbusinessrescue.co.uk/business-insolvency/wrongful-trading&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit19"><label>19</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Phelps, Kathy B. Deepening Insolvency as a Cause of Action and as a Theory of Damages, &lt;http://www.dgdk.com/tasks/sites/dgdk/assets/image/AIRIDeepeningInsolvencyFinal.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Phelps, Kathy B. Deepening Insolvency as a Cause of Action and as a Theory of Damages, &lt;http://www.dgdk.com/tasks/sites/dgdk/assets/image/AIRIDeepeningInsolvencyFinal.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit20"><label>20</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Posner, Richard A. A Theory of Negligence, 1 J. Legal Stud. 29, 42 (1972), available at &lt;http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3089&amp;context=journal_articles&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Posner, Richard A. A Theory of Negligence, 1 J. Legal Stud. 29, 42 (1972), available at &lt;http://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3089&amp;context=journal_articles&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit21"><label>21</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Rubin, Paul. New Liability under ‘Deepening Insolvency:’ The Search for Deep Pocket, 23 Am. Bankr. Inst. J. 50 (2004), available at &lt;http://www.herrick.com/siteFiles/Publications/805D53435768CE5436A02FF829D497C8.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Rubin, Paul. New Liability under ‘Deepening Insolvency:’ The Search for Deep Pocket, 23 Am. Bankr. Inst. J. 50 (2004), available at &lt;http://www.herrick.com/siteFiles/Publications/805D53435768CE5436A02FF829D497C8.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit22"><label>22</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Schillig, Michael. ‘Deepening Insolvency’ – Liability for Wrongful Trading in the United States?, 30 Company Lawyer 298, 300 (2009).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Schillig, Michael. ‘Deepening Insolvency’ – Liability for Wrongful Trading in the United States?, 30 Company Lawyer 298, 300 (2009).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit23"><label>23</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Schulte, Richard. Wrongful Trading: An Impotent Remedy?, 4 Journal of Financial Crime 38 (1996). doi:10.1108/eb025753</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Schulte, Richard. Wrongful Trading: An Impotent Remedy?, 4 Journal of Financial Crime 38 (1996). doi:10.1108/eb025753</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit24"><label>24</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Smith, Mike. What is Wrongful Trading and How Can I Avoid Getting Myself into Trouble with Creditors such as HMRC?, &lt;http://www.companydebt.com/directors-support/what-is-wrongful-trading&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Smith, Mike. What is Wrongful Trading and How Can I Avoid Getting Myself into Trouble with Creditors such as HMRC?, &lt;http://www.companydebt.com/directors-support/what-is-wrongful-trading&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit25"><label>25</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Tully, John. Plumbing the Depth of Corporate Litigation: Reforming the Deeping Insolvency Theory, 2013 u. Ill. L. Rev. 2087, 2108, available at &lt;http://www.illinoislawreview.org/wp-content/ilr-content/articles/2013/5/Tully.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Tully, John. Plumbing the Depth of Corporate Litigation: Reforming the Deeping Insolvency Theory, 2013 u. Ill. L. Rev. 2087, 2108, available at &lt;http://www.illinoislawreview.org/wp-content/ilr-content/articles/2013/5/Tully.pdf&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit26"><label>26</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Werdnik, Rainer. Wrongful Trading Provision – Is It Efficient?, 25 Insolvency Intelligence 81, 84–85 (2012).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Werdnik, Rainer. Wrongful Trading Provision – Is It Efficient?, 25 Insolvency Intelligence 81, 84–85 (2012).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit27"><label>27</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Zipursky, Benjamin C. A Theory of Punitive Damages, 84 Tex. L. Rev. 105 (2005), available at &lt;http://ssrn.com/abstract=705281&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Zipursky, Benjamin C. A Theory of Punitive Damages, 84 Tex. L. Rev. 105 (2005), available at &lt;http://ssrn.com/abstract=705281&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit28"><label>28</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Zywicki, Todd. Public Choice and Tort Reform (george Mason university School of Law, Law and Economics Working Paper No. 00-36, October 2000), &lt;http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=244658&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Zywicki, Todd. Public Choice and Tort Reform (george Mason university School of Law, Law and Economics Working Paper No. 00-36, October 2000), &lt;http://papers.ssrn.com/abstract_id=244658&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit29"><label>29</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Абрамов А.И. Понятие функций права // Журнал российского права. 2006. № 2 [Abramov A.I. Ponyatie funktsii prava // Zhurnal rossiiskogo prava. 2006. No. 2 [Andrey I. Abramov, The Notion of Law Functions, 2006(2) Journal of Russian Law]].</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Абрамов А.И. Понятие функций права // Журнал российского права. 2006. № 2 [Abramov A.I. Ponyatie funktsii prava // Zhurnal rossiiskogo prava. 2006. No. 2 [Andrey I. Abramov, The Notion of Law Functions, 2006(2) Journal of Russian Law]].</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit30"><label>30</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Курбатов А. Субсидиарная ответственность руководителей при несостоя- тельности (банкротстве) возглавляемых ими кредитных организаций // Хозяйство и право. 2007. № 7 [Kurbatov A. Subsidiarnaya otvetsvennost’ rukovoditelei pri nesostoyatel’nosti (bankrotstve) vosglavlyaemykh imi kreditnykh organisatsii // Khozyaistvo i pravo. 2007. No. 7 [Aleksey Kurbatov, The Subsidiary Liability of the Direc- tors for Insolvency of the Companies, 2007(7) Economy and Law]].</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Курбатов А. Субсидиарная ответственность руководителей при несостоя- тельности (банкротстве) возглавляемых ими кредитных организаций // Хозяйство и право. 2007. № 7 [Kurbatov A. Subsidiarnaya otvetsvennost’ rukovoditelei pri nesostoyatel’nosti (bankrotstve) vosglavlyaemykh imi kreditnykh organisatsii // Khozyaistvo i pravo. 2007. No. 7 [Aleksey Kurbatov, The Subsidiary Liability of the Direc- tors for Insolvency of the Companies, 2007(7) Economy and Law]].</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit31"><label>31</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Мирошников В.А. Банкротство кредитных организаций – проблемы право- применительной практики [Miroshnikov V.A. Bankrotstvo kreditnykh organizatsii – problemy pravoprimenitel’noi praktiki [Valery A. Miroshnikov, Insolvency of Banks: Questions of Practice]], Agenstvo po strakhovaniyu vkladov (Feb. 18, 2008), &lt;http://asv.org.ru/agency/appearance/286768/?sphrase_id=747589&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Мирошников В.А. Банкротство кредитных организаций – проблемы право- применительной практики [Miroshnikov V.A. Bankrotstvo kreditnykh organizatsii – problemy pravoprimenitel’noi praktiki [Valery A. Miroshnikov, Insolvency of Banks: Questions of Practice]], Agenstvo po strakhovaniyu vkladov (Feb. 18, 2008), &lt;http://asv.org.ru/agency/appearance/286768/?sphrase_id=747589&gt; (accessed Aug. 11, 2015).</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref><ref id="cit32"><label>32</label><citation-alternatives><mixed-citation xml:lang="ru">Спирина Т.А. «Снятие корпоративной вуали» через механизм привлечения к субсидиарной ответственности в рамках дела о банкротстве // Вестник Пермского университета: Серия «Юридические науки». 2014. № 1 [Spirina T.A. ‘Snyatie korporativnoi vuali’ cherez mekhanizm privlecheniya k subsidiarnoi otvetstvennosti v ramkakh dela o bankrotstve // Vetsnik Permskogo universiteta: Seriya ‘Yuridicheskie nauki’. 2014. No. 1 [Tatiana A. Spirina, ‘Piercing the Corporate Veil’ through Subsidiary Liability in Bankruptcy Case, 2014(1) Bulletin of Perm university: Law]].</mixed-citation><mixed-citation xml:lang="en">Спирина Т.А. «Снятие корпоративной вуали» через механизм привлечения к субсидиарной ответственности в рамках дела о банкротстве // Вестник Пермского университета: Серия «Юридические науки». 2014. № 1 [Spirina T.A. ‘Snyatie korporativnoi vuali’ cherez mekhanizm privlecheniya k subsidiarnoi otvetstvennosti v ramkakh dela o bankrotstve // Vetsnik Permskogo universiteta: Seriya ‘Yuridicheskie nauki’. 2014. No. 1 [Tatiana A. Spirina, ‘Piercing the Corporate Veil’ through Subsidiary Liability in Bankruptcy Case, 2014(1) Bulletin of Perm university: Law]].</mixed-citation></citation-alternatives></ref></ref-list><fn-group><fn fn-type="conflict"><p>The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.</p></fn></fn-group></back></article>
